The Light Between Oceans

Antonia45 stars

12 March 2012 at 2:38pm

I love this book! With its moving and extraordinary story, effortlessly beautiful writing, fiercely real characters and evocative setting, THE LIGHT BETWEEN OCEANS is a powerful novel that will resonate with everybody, lingering in your thoughts long after you’ve finished reading.

Shelley5 stars

16 April 2012 at 3:27pm

The Light Between Oceans is a compelling debut from Australian born author M.L. (Margot) Stedman. Set on a tiny island off the coast of Western Australia, where the the Indian Ocean meets the Southern Ocean, this novel explores the haunting consequences of love and desire. Tom Sherbourne is the lighthouse keeper at Janus Rock, a position that has afforded him some measure of peace after the horrors of World War One. During his infrequent visits to the mainland at Port Partageuse, he develops a relationship with the spirited Isabel Graysmark whom he eventually marries and the two create a life together on Rock. Their bliss is marred only by Isabel's repeated miscarriages so when a boat drifts ashore carrying a dead man and squalling infant girl, Isabel convinces Tom that they have been granted a gift. Lucy becomes the light of their lives but Tom's unease with the situation never dissipates and when he learns the devastating truth he is torn between right and wrong, guilt and innocence, love and duty. With stunning sensitivity, Stedman explores the grey, murky waters between the absolutes of right and wrong. Decisions made with good intentions, with love, prove ultimately to have consequences that cause irreparable harm. A heartbreaking tale that has strong emotional impact I found myself equally torn as the story unfolds, my sympathies lay with all the protagonists, two grieving women and a man who wants to do right by both of them. Joy is often juxtaposed by a sense of dread and tension seeps from pages. Tom is a complex man, shaped by tragedy and war, he clings to the ideals of love, honour and duty. He knows how the lines between right and wrong can blur given circumstances and strives to do the right thing always. In this instance he fulfils his obligation to his wife, to love and honour her, by allowing himself to be persuaded to keep the child. When he discovers the consequences of that decision he is torn when honour and duty call for the child to be returned to the mother who still grieves her loss. I admired Tom for many reasons, not the least being his genuine emotional turmoil and strength of character. Isabel is quite young when she marries Tom and moves to the Rock. She is feisty and headstrong but has a naivete and vulnerability that is endearing. I could not help but sympathise with her as she mourned her lost children, having experienced several miscarriages myself, and identified with her joy over the miraculous gift of Lucy. When Isabel's world falls apart I was horribly torn for Hannah is equally, perhaps even more, as deserving of sympathy. Isabel's violent reaction to Tom is shocking, if understandable and her final choice is a brave, if heart rending one. It is rare that young children have well formed character in novels but Stedman achieves this in The Light Between Oceans. Lucy is as skillfully created and whole as the adult protagonists. Stedman captures the unique atmosphere of time and place. Set in the aftermath of World War One her characters are reeling from the losses of the war. In the tiny town of Port Partaguese many of the boys and men who went to fight never returned and those that did, were forever changed. Isabel grieved her adored brothers and her miscarriages compound her sense of loss. She senses what proves to be true, that a grandchild will help heal her own parents broken hearts. For Tom, the memories of war, of death and destruction, are soothed by life on Janus Rock and Isabel's love, but are never far from his mind. The author creates a spectacular atmosphere on Janus Rock, the tiny island that houses the lighthouse cared for by Tom and Isabel. The isolated splendour of the place is vividly described but Janus Rock is both an idyllic haven and a lonely outcrop. Tom and Isabel have contact with the outside world only once every three months and can return to mainland only once every few years. The Light Between Oceans is a stunning novel, evocative and lyrical. Rich with emotion, extraordinary characters and story, this is a wonderful read, I happily recommend.